Phoenix’s Top Cheesecake Destinations for Dessert Enthusiasts!

Laura Williams

Photo by Tina Guina on Unsplash

Phoenix, Arizona is a city that is known for its diverse culinary scene. From Mexican to Italian, there is no shortage of delicious food options in this desert city. However, one dessert that stands out among the rest is cheesecake. Whether you prefer classic New York-style or something more unique, Phoenix has some of the best cheesecake options in the country.

Cheesecake is a dessert that originated in ancient Greece and was later adopted by the Romans. While Greek and Roman cuisine may not be as popular in Phoenix as other cuisines, there are still some great options for those looking to try something new. Greek cuisine, for example, is known for its use of fresh herbs and spices, as well as its emphasis on healthy ingredients like olive oil and vegetables. Italian cuisine, on the other hand, is known for its rich sauces and hearty pasta dishes.

If you’re a cheesecake lover, then you’re in luck because Phoenix has some of the best options around. From classic New York-style to more unique flavors like lavender and honey, there is something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a casual spot to grab a slice or a fancy restaurant for a special occasion, Phoenix has it all. In this article, we’ll be exploring some of the best cheesecake options in the city, so get ready to indulge in some sweet, creamy goodness.

Banham’s Cheesecake

Banham’s Cheesecake - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Banham’s Cheesecake – Photo Source

2836 E Indian School Rd Ste A3 Phoenix
(602) 824-8657
Banham’s Cheesecake Menu

Banham’s Cheesecake is a must-visit for anyone who loves cheesecake. The peanut butter cheesecake is a must-try, with its dense and rich texture and light peanut butter flavor. The chocolate on top is the perfect complement, without being overpowering. The Oreo cheesecake is also a great choice, and the fruit flavors like strawberry, blueberry, and coconut are definitely worth trying. The prices are very reasonable, especially when compared to other dessert shops in the area.

While there was one negative review about plastic found in a slice of cake, it seems to be an isolated incident and not reflective of the overall quality of the cheesecakes. The customer service is excellent, with a friendly owner who greets you and explains all the flavors available. The shop is clean and inviting, with limited seating but a friendly atmosphere.

The banana pudding cheesecake is a standout, with a light and fluffy texture and fresh flavor that impressed even out-of-town family members. The key lime and eggnog flavors are also delicious. And for those who become addicted to Banham’s Cheesecake, there’s a stamp card that rewards you with a free slice after your 10th purchase.

See also  Phoenix Bakery and Dessert Guide: Where to Find the Best Treats in the City

Overall, Banham’s Cheesecake is a gem of a dessert shop that provides an array of yummy cheat day treats that are worth every single calorie. The staff is friendly, professional, accommodating, and just all around delightful. Don’t miss out on this delicious experience!

Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole

Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole – Photo Source

15414 N 7th St Ste 6 Phoenix
(602) 332-7346
Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole Menu

Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth or a love for savory pies. The reviews speak for themselves, with customers raving about the delicious pies and quiches. The crust is a standout feature, with reviewers calling it the best they’ve ever tasted. From the raspberry cheesecake to the coconut cream pie, every flavor is crafted with love and care. Even if you’re looking for something not on the menu, the friendly staff is willing to go the extra mile to make your pie dreams come true. And if you’re in the mood for something savory, the spinach mushroom feta quiche and biscuit sandwich are highly recommended. Don’t miss out on this gem in the desert – Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole is a true delight for the taste buds.

The Velvet Buttercream

Mini New York Cheesecakes @ The Velvet Buttercream - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Mini New York Cheesecakes @ The Velvet Buttercream – Photo Source

702 W Camelback Rd Ste 5 Phoenix
(602) 734-1408
The Velvet Buttercream Menu

The Velvet Buttercream is a hidden gem in Phoenix that you simply must try. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted with friendly faces and a warm atmosphere. The desserts are truly something special, and you can tell that Chef Aaron pours his heart and soul into every creation. The cakes are moist and flavorful, and the icing is perfectly balanced – not too sweet, but just right. The signature items are baked from scratch, and you can taste the difference. The Trunchbull Cupcake is a must-try, and the NY Mini Cheesecake, Macarons, and Cannoli are all equally delicious. The Arizona Strawberry Shortcake is a family favorite and is always requested by our loved ones. The customer service is exceptional, and the team is always willing to go above and beyond to make sure you’re happy. Even when I had to reschedule my order due to unexpected circumstances, they were so understanding and accommodating. Chef Aaron is a true artist, and his creativity shines through in every design. The attention to detail is impressive, and the cakes are always beautiful inside and out. I highly recommend The Velvet Buttercream for any occasion – whether it’s a housewarming party, a book signing, a wedding, or just a sweet treat for yourself. You won’t be disappointed.

See also  Savoring Spain in the Desert: Phoenix's Premier Spanish Eateries

Arai Pastry

Lemon Cheesecake @ Arai Pastry - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
Lemon Cheesecake @ Arai Pastry – Photo Source

1335 W University Dr Ste 4 Tempe
(480) 966-9002
Arai Pastry Menu

Arai Pastry is a must-visit bakery in Tempe, Arizona. The reviews speak for themselves, with customers raving about the delicious treats they offer. From the perfect birthday cakes to the amazing flan, there is something for everyone at Arai Pastry. The stuffed bread and iced green tea drink smoothie are also highly recommended.

Even with a negative review, Arai Pastry still shines. While they require masks, it’s important to remember that they are doing their part to keep everyone safe.

But the real star of the show is the Milk bread (Shoku pan). As a Japanese person, the reviewer was amazed and shocked by how good it was. They’ve tried many $10 rich shokupan in Tokyo and all over Japan, but Arai Pastry’s Shoku pan is BETTER. The perfect amount of sweetness, milkiness, and richness make it the softest shokupan they’ve ever had.

Overall, Arai Pastry is a bakery that truly deserves a visit. The family-owned business puts love and care into every treat they make, and it shows. Don’t miss out on the Milk bread and other delicious flavors. Cheers to the family!

The Sicilian Baker

New Your Cheesecake @ The Sicilian Baker - <a href="">Photo Source</a>
New Your Cheesecake @ The Sicilian Baker – Photo Source

15530 N Tatum Blvd Ste 140 Phoenix
(602) 612-5590
The Sicilian Baker Menu None

The Sicilian Baker is a must-visit for anyone in Scottsdale looking for delicious Italian pastries and desserts. The cannolis are a standout item, with a variety of fillings available to suit any taste. The gelatos are also a hit, with many flavors to choose from that are sure to please both kids and adults. The decor of the bakery is modern and clean, adding to the overall experience. Even with a grand opening, the line was out the door, but the wait was worth it.

While there were a few negative reviews, it’s important to note that everyone has their off days. The tiramisu may not have been up to par for one reviewer, but there are plenty of other desserts to try. Another reviewer was disappointed with the selection and service, but it’s possible that they visited during a busy time. It’s always worth giving a place a second chance, especially when the cannolis are as good as they are at The Sicilian Baker.

See also  Savor the Spices: Exploring Cajun Food in Phoenix

Overall, The Sicilian Baker is a great spot for anyone looking for authentic Italian pastries and desserts. The cannolis and gelatos are a must-try, and the modern decor adds to the overall experience. Don’t let a few negative reviews deter you from visiting this gem in Scottsdale.

Personal Recommendation

Having explored Phoenix’s diverse cheesecake scene, it’s impossible not to express enthusiasm for these delightful establishments. Each bakery, from Banham’s Cheesecake to The Sicilian Baker, holds a unique charm and culinary expertise that captivates the palate. The peanut butter cheesecake at Banham’s is a revelation, boasting a dense texture and subtle peanut butter notes that elevate the dessert experience. Meanwhile, Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole, with its standout crust and inventive flavors, offers a symphony of tastes that lingers in the memory.

At The Velvet Buttercream, Chef Aaron’s commitment to quality shines through, crafting moist and flavorful cakes that are both visually stunning and a true testament to his culinary artistry. Arai Pastry, with its Japanese-inspired treats, particularly the exceptional Milk bread, showcases a fusion of flavors that is both unexpected and delightful. Lastly, The Sicilian Baker, with its authentic Italian pastries, delivers an immersive experience with cannolis and gelatos that transport you straight to the heart of Italy. Each bakery is a culinary gem, making Phoenix a haven for cheesecake enthusiasts seeking a symphony of flavors in every bite.


In the tapestry of Phoenix’s vibrant culinary landscape, the cheesecake offerings from Banham’s, Mamma Toledo’s, The Velvet Buttercream, Arai Pastry, and The Sicilian Baker stand out as exquisite threads, woven together to create a symphony of flavors. Each establishment brings a unique flair to the dessert experience, making the city a haven for cheesecake aficionados. From innovative twists to classic indulgences, these bakeries have mastered the art of crafting sweet delights that leave an enduring impression. Phoenix, with its array of cheesecake gems, beckons dessert enthusiasts to savor every moment, inviting them on a culinary journey that is as diverse as it is delectable. As the cheesecake scene continues to evolve, these establishments serve as pillars, embodying the city’s commitment to culinary excellence and ensuring that every sweet tooth finds its perfect match in Phoenix.

Explore the delectable world of Phoenix’s finest desserts in the comprehensive guide: PHOENIX BAKERY AND DESSERT GUIDE: WHERE TO FIND THE BEST TREATS IN THE CITY.

Embark on a culinary adventure through Phoenix’s top restaurants with the guide: DISCOVERING PHOENIX’S BEST AMERICAN CUISINE: A CULINARY JOURNEY THROUGH THE CITY’S TOP RESTAURANTS.

Leave a Comment

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from You can learn more about our editorial policies here.